Espresso shot being pulled with cream

Myths & Facts

Does Good Crema Mean Quality Coffee?

Find out if this marketing claim holds up to science

· Myths & Facts · By Kelly Urquhart

Espresso Crema adverts c. 1948
Italian adverts c. 1948 for Gaggia Espresso Machines featuring “crema caffè naturale”

The Claim

In 1947, an Italian inventor by the name of, Achille Gaggia, patented his spring-loaded lever piston coffee machine, known today as the espresso machine. Milan locals largely criticized his invention for producing a soap-like “scum” on top.

To overcome the stigma from the public, he rebranded the coffee scum as “crema caffè naturale” claiming it was a mark of superior purity and his machines produced “coffee that creates its own cream”, requiring no milk.


Samuel Cate Prescott studying coffee c. 1923
Samuel Cate Prescott, former Dean of MIT's school of science, who proved that coffee is in fact "safe & healthy" to drink, c. 1923

The Science

Gaggia’s machine was actually emulsifying the oils and acids in the coffee, trapping carbon dioxide in small bubbles that formed a crema-scum on top. In recent independent studies (not funded by coffee producing corporations), biochemical scientists found that:

  • Higher bar pressure-fed machines produced more crema, even from stale pre-ground coffee1
  • Cheaper Robusta beans2 and sugar-roasted blends produced more crema
  • High quality coffee typically brews with little to no crema
  • Sommelier quality testing revealed that coffee shots with crema scored lower than those without crema

The Conclusion

If you’re looking for high quality coffee and judging the quality by how much crema you get, Gaggia’s 78 year-old scheme will leave you chasing a marketing myth. Here's four important things you should consider when searching for high quality coffee:

Roasting coffee beans in a stainless roaster
Stainless roaster in action at Pachamama Coffee Farmer's Roastery
  1. Find out where it is grown and how is it farmed
    Organic high-elevation coffee produces slower growing, denser coffee beans which give a better flavor profile.
  2. Find out how it is shipped from farmer to roaster
    The humid jungle environment is ideal for growing coffee but it requires careful handling to prevent mold toxins from contaminating the beans.
  3. Find out how it is roasted
    Manually operated small-batch roasting machines with stainless steel drums are essential for producing high quality coffee.
  4. Find out how it is packaged
    Coffee is highly susceptible to flavor influencing which means the liner of the bag makes all the difference for long-term storage. Informal studies show that properly cooled beans bagged within hours of roasting and sealed in natural packaging can stay fresh for up to two years3 (something our team also tested when considering which coffee to carry).

Our Quality Coffee Recommendation: Pachamama Coffee Farmers not only fulfill the minimal requirements for high quality coffee, but they extend themselves far beyond to produce coffee beans on another level. We stand behind their brand and highly recommend their coffee as some of the best in the world

All posts

Mellifera Loving Life